Our Climate Change Emergency & Three-Legged Bar-Stool Survival, Three Videos


I build a very strong scientific case showing that our climate system is spiraling out of control, threatening our very survival on Earth. I then discuss how government leaders around the planet must declare a climate change emergency. This would open up money and resources to deploy the three-legged-bar-stool survival strategies:

Leg 1: slash fossil fuel emissions;
Leg 2: deploy carbon dioxide removal tech;
Leg 3: cool the Arctic.

First video, below:

———- ———-

Also, below the third video, be sure NOT to miss Arctic Methane Emergency Group’s John Nissen’s letter, produced as a proposal for COP22.  About AMEG, here.  Version 2 is approved for sharing here (at bottom of post).
———- ———-

Video Two, below

———- ———-

Here is a copy of the powerpoint slide presentation, called: ‘paul_climate_emergency_barstool_nov_18_2016-final‘.  Cloud version here for those of you who might not have or use Microsoft Office–has fifty images.

[dk:  the version from the last post had fifty-two images.  And similar as it might look to the one from three days ago–for those of you who use or look at such things, Paul tells us, they are not the same.]
———- ———-

Video Three, below

Please consider supporting my work with a donation, through the PayPal donate link.  Very easy to use.
———- ———-

“The era of procrastination, of half measures, of soothing and baffling expedience of delays, is coming to its close. In its place we are entering a period of consequences.”
“They go on in strange paradox, decided only to be undecided, resolved to be irresolute, adamant for drift, solid for fluidity, all-powerful to be impotent”¦ Owing to past neglect, in the face of the plainest warnings, we have entered upon a period of danger. The era of procrastination, of half measures, of soothing and baffling expedience of delays, is coming to its close. In its place we are entering a period of consequences”¦. We cannot avoid this period, we are in it now”, Sir  Winston Churchill.
.———- ———-


For the attention of COP22

The climate community and consensus of scientists, represented by IPCC, had assumed that, by reducing net emissions of CO2 to zero, global warming could be halted. They had also assumed that such a reduction would halt Arctic warming, by the process which has kept Arctic warming proportional to global warming but amplified by a factor of around two.

Unfortunately evidence indicates that these assumptions are no longer valid. The Earth System is showing signs of moving ever faster away from the old norm of the past thousands of years: the Holocene period of remarkably stable temperature, climate and sea level, which allowed crops to be grown, trade to take place and civilisation to develop. The changes are happening most rapidly in the Arctic where there is acceleration in warming and melting, mainly due to the “albedo positive feedback” effect whereby, as snow and sea ice retreat, more heat is absorbed by exposed land and water.

There are four significant effects of this accelerated warming in the Arctic:
accelerated melt of the Greenland Ice Sheet with associated sea level rise;
accelerated discharge of methane from permafrost both under the seabed and under the land surface with associated greenhouse warming effect;
accelerated disruption of the jet stream with growing weather extremes in the Northern Hemisphere;
a growing contribution of radiative forcing to the planet’s energy budget, which will inevitably lead to additional warming of the rest of the planet.

Considering that the planet is already suffering from climate change and sea level rise, which both are liable to get worse with levels of greenhouse gases rising and accelerated warming in the Arctic:-

COP should adopt a new overall objective of restoring the planet to the safe conditions enjoyed for thousands of years of the Holocene. In this process:

(i) global temperature should be kept below 1.5C with respect to its pre-industrial level;
(ii) CO2 in the atmosphere should be reduced to its pre-industrial level, which involves a massive CDR effort coupled with drastic cuts in CO2 emissions;
(iii) emissions of other significant GHGs (especially methane) should be reduced to pre-industrial levels;
(iv) the Arctic should be quickly cooled as a precaution against further sea ice retreat, further escalation of sea level rise, further escalation of methane release from permafrost, and further disruption of the jet stream leading to further rise in Northern Hemisphere extreme weather events;
(v) the Arctic albedo should restored to the level of at least thirty years ago.

To make such a huge undertaking acceptable to world leaders, it is necessary to show that there is a good business case, with jobs and food security. And there has to be a means of funding which is equitable and allows businesses to optimise their profits without jeopardising the health of the planet.

Arguably there is one industry which is capable of funding the CDR and methane suppression, namely the fossil fuel industry. If world leaders can persuade the industry to pay for CDR and methane suppression by taking a levy on carbon taken out of the ground, then the industry can maximise profits while protecting the planet at the same time.

There needs to be a level playing field, so that all exploiters of fossil fuel pay a carbon levy, based on the greenhouse gas emissions it will cause. Thus CCS will effectively obtain a rebate. Exploiters of natural gas will have a levy based not only on CO2 emitted on consumption but also on fugitive methane.

Since it is not possible to determine in advance the costs of CDR and methane suppression, there will need to be an initial levy which is ramped up over time according to the effectiveness in removing CO2 and suppressing methane. The fossil fuel industry will have a financial incentive to make these processes efficient and avoid undue increases in the levy which would hit their bottom line.

There needs to be some regulation, since it is desirable that the CDR and methane suppression is done in ways which have benefits for housing, food production, water management, job security, biodiversity, etc. This is where the UN has a key role: in setting the regulation mechanisms and the means of policing them.

There are many techniques for CDR and methane suppression which have such benefits in forestry, agriculture and aquaculture.

Forest management can ensure that carbon is captured for the long term, with the benefits of providing wood for buildings and increasing biodiversity. Agricultural practice can increase carbon in soil through the development of crops with longer roots.

Crop residues can be heated pyrolytically to produce a combination of biofuel and biochar, the latter being returned to the soil for improvement of crop yields and water management, also reducing the requirements for artificial fertiliser which is carbon intensive in its production.

Methane suppression using diatoms can likewise improve crop production, e.g. in paddy fields. It can purify local water supplies for the benefits of crops and human consumption. Dispersal of diatoms with appropriate nutrients over wetlands, lakes and oceans can reduce methane, while oxygenating water and stimulating the food chain. Thus fish stocks and other marine food sources are increased, providing food for human consumption as well as increasing sustainable biomass for the planet as a whole.

Another CDR technique with great potential involves the crushing of olivine rock and its accelerated weathering to remove CO2 and create carbon-retaining substances. This technique has a major direct benefit of increasing ocean alkalinity, e.g. when the crushed rock is spread on beaches where wave action can accelerate its weathering.

If such techniques are insufficient, or cannot be brought up to speed quickly enough, then direct air capture has to be considered. At present it is extremely expensive compared to other techniques. But this cost may come down to make it competitive, so intensive research and development effort is recommended.

The cooling of the Arctic and restoration of albedo has obvious benefits for the wild life and indigenous peoples of the Arctic, e.g. polar bears which rely on sea ice for their hunting. There is also potential for capturing methane as a fuel; methane is bubbling up from the ocean seabed in vast quantities, and might be captured under the sea ice or deliberately created “ice shields”.

This is an example of an opportunity for methane suppression to be combined with albedo enhancement. Another example is the floating of mats containing diatoms and nutrients, which can enhance albedo while helping to remove CO2, reduce acidification, oxygenate the water and promote methanotrophs which digest methane dissolved in the water. In this case there is an added benefit of promoting the marine food chain for the benefit of marine life and fishing.

To get the process started, COP22 should consider:

• a new initiative combining aggressive CDR, methane
suppression and CO2 emissions reduction, such that global
warming can be halted at 1.5C or less within a few decades;

• a new initiative to cool the Arctic and
restore albedo to the level thirty years ago;

• an overall plan to restore the Earth System to
such conditions as allowed civilisation to flourish
over the past thousands of years known as the Holocene;

• an initiative of public education in the
understanding of this plan;

• seed funding for promising new technical
developments in CDR, methane suppression
and albedo enhancement;

• a conference bringing together representatives
of governments and the fossil fuel industry to
present the business case for funding large-scale
out of a carbon levy.


About paulbeckwith

Well known climate science educator; Part-time Geography professor (climatology, oceanography, environmental issues), University of Ottawa. Physicist. Engineer. Master's Degree in Science in Laser Optics, Bachelors of Engineering, in Engineering Physics. Won Association of Professional Engineers of Ontario gold medal. Also interested in investment and start-ups in climate solutions, renewable energy and energy efficiency. Avid chess player, and likes restoring old homes. Married with children.
This entry was posted in a New Video, Uncategorized and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

19 Responses to Our Climate Change Emergency & Three-Legged Bar-Stool Survival, Three Videos

  1. cynthiajoanmorrison says:

    Stopping clear-cutting & keeping our forests intact will solve alot. Also stopping monoculture farming will solve alot.


  2. cynthiajoanmorrison says:

    Hemp can amend the soil pretty fast. We need our topsoil back. Amend the infertile soil with Hemp…..creating fertile soil…& no toxic chemicals will be needed to grow crops….as long as crops are grown with Bio-diverse techniques….such as permaculture. Hemp can also be grown to use to make bricks & concrete for building materials, instead of wood. We dont need to cut down the forests for lumber. We really really don’t.


  3. cynthiajoanmorrison says:

    Give people carbon credit rebates for going solar &/or buying EV’s.


  4. cynthiajoanmorrison says:

    Read Tom Rand’s books….or watch him on Ted Talks….the answers are all there already. We just need to elect the right gov’t to get the right action.


  5. jarcl says:

    A clearly articulated presentation by Paul that clearly shows how serious the problem is.


  6. Dale Lanan says:

    The sudden advent of a situational awareness of danger present, warrants use of Act of God writ as if a play that is still being written on an island amidst a clashing at Earth’s runaway overheat, heck’ -even our ‘good’ books are archaic to locus of Pyramid scheme of the enslavement of the Midas Touch, debt based off-loading of consequence for profit, for profit.
    We need to dash the fires of Hell as if using water of life to quell fire’s embers to make activated carbon to sequester in soil and work for Real instead of taking the force of Contract standing like a tidal wave from hell’s inability to stop dream$ that is so loaded with ultimate consequence, error..
    -This is no dream we need to wake to the danger upon us and undo closed system entropy force..


  7. Pingback: A Emergência Climática e a Estratégia para a Nossa Sobrevivência

  8. Pingback: Carta ao COP22 pelo Grupo de Emergência pelo Metano no Ártico - Alterações Climáticas

  9. Dale Lanan says:

    Trying to get US flipped back from International Corporate Coup is like flying a hang glider over hot lava
    Trying to get World flipped back from Pecuniary System Isolation profit taking at lasso of tender is like launch of a hang golden opportunity to rectify the Solar Radiance to Normal for Biosphere.
    Time~ applies unexpected results if ta, snap of awareness sweeps the world of system isolation so the work we do naturally tends to help restore the Biosphere of Earth to Strength in Hope of y = Harmonic Resonance at Distance Not. In my Book id appears as if Kindness to God at Silence.
    But Fate does not necessarily apply if we muster the guts to Give Earth Standing at Law Real in r =Relativity Experiment ‘Test of Theory 2C’ ~HZ~Time Forward 7 Generations for the children all,,


    • Dale Lanan says:

      I’m sure about the nature of Closed System Thermodynamics forcing Entropy in time forward. Where I am relative – so having flown and worked with thought experiments in quest of sideswiping the world into keeping Earth alive. But Hot Lava is ~ to child Icarus to his father telling him not to be lax or show off – that a simple snap ta of awareness can aim the world to work in same direction as what Earth Biosphere does overall to keep cool the harmonic nature of a garden flying through space in a one off place and time..
      But is it repeat of or irrevocable and where are we now relative to too late is precedent.


      • Dale Lanan says:

        Skirting Crimean War -into poetry and and legend –Time Rode the 600 in acceleration of Time Forward to see Why -why the Or order ta Tap of a Drum was like that of of Logic but the officer in employ of a Trump Midas Madness saw glory and time like a dream 2C
        What was unacceptable danger to the sound of the horses of the light brigade into War..
        But No means no even in battle when the place is riven with road noise of time forward..
        I’ll send a drone view for order of War and a volley of cannons zeroing in on location ~ The Road to ring fence hell’s fire and fury – from insider involved in tabloid mag West.
        Where East is East and West is West but Corporate Consolidation at Ends of Earth Not…
        The Fact Remains, Earth Atmosphere is Loaded for Bear and the people are like sheep


  10. Dale Lanan says:

    To the World of Poetry Said He, As the World Slid like Silently in a Debris Flow of time forward.
    The Rain, the rain dumped from cloud of pecuniary madness a Trump upon the Land on High
    The accumulation of Wealth Ill Gotten without rear guard to keep the Work of Others on Earth
    Technique, Tech assisted biosphere function to speak clearly in defense of Earth and her Harbor, Where East is East and West is West and you Can Not Find An App or for hiring Apache to hunt Apache and grind the Stones of Mountains of Time Forward To the Sea.. No, No Said He to man who gave order to Charge for the Light Brigade over the Pecuniary Principle of System Isolation.
    But the Slip of the Slide of Poetry’s Mountain Heard the Raw Hide Pelt Ride of the Children Real.
    The Corral of the penned up Apache in Reservation essential toe to Kick of the Field Goal Earth could not contain the thrill of hearing the thrill of the ride of a Raw Hide Sled Down Sheer Thrill…
    For the Symmetry of real Tiger is in hearing the news that perhaps the large Cat from South in before the Wall of the Trumped Up madness closed off the Native Peoples South, Soon South..
    Where Latitude is Concerned with Heat Capture differential bar differential divided by 2 pi time…….- What about second differential to North where the Mistakes of sic Too Late So, So much Rain of Pecuniary Debris that it is impossible for Earth Biosphere Function to Continue….
    The Eye of the Time Tiger thought Bravely like prey on the run- Head for the Hills and Pray Fast…


  11. Dale Lanan says:

    There is an e for energy at work in the world to Test planet life form where brain power hit pay dirt.
    The miners for More showed their colors and sang Loud, like horse soldiers loudly “Yo, Yo Echo’ as they passed the valley outcrop.” For the Time Tiger heard the fearsome thunder of Cannon in Battles.
    The struggle and little toy wind ups as the soldiers of thought did their business for Cannon fodder $
    The Earth Shudders gaining e for entropy and m for moment~ toward and in keeping w heat in a enlargement of real pressure surrounding center of Gravity flying through space,; As if a ‘Cross of the Moment’ Certainty hit reality thermodynamics.: The Echo Replied Not the song of the soldiers hooves but the reflection of thought within the minds of the horseback cavalry..: To what fearsome symmetry belongs the a Backwards ~thought of the horses hooves \-/
    The valley of the Dry Bones and the cliffs of outcrop, if their story be told told of Time up.:
    Now I as a citizen w hope try to prep for a sermon on Earth Day describing how Jesus and Martin Luther King Jr are heat sinks,, But the number of directions to go, what to say first to Echo God 2C, to see showdown of the Universe in real time w the undoing of the basis of pecuniary Fling…
    Sounds silly but the Laws of Thermodynamics and God are not divergent. We can muster courage and attempt to right the Carbonate Balance of Song as we pass Outcrop Echo 1..


  12. Pingback: Stopping Hothouse Earth | Situations Vacant

  13. Pingback: GUEST BLOG: Dave Brownz – Stopping Hothouse Earth – « The Daily Blog

Leave a Reply to Dale Lanan Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s